winter_blossom: (Golden-haired beauty)
It feels kind of pretentious to ramble about my personal opinions when I'm not a distinguished person in fandom, because who even cares about what I like? But then again, I'd love to come back to this page 10 years into the future (or something) and see how my tastes have changed over time, if at all, so for once I'm making a post for/about myself!

And, yep, this is the Either/Or Meme that was first posted by @solo here and has been making its way around.

Long-winded rambling under the cut... )
winter_blossom: (Default)
30. Prompt for a fanwork

I know there's not much point in my doing this, since I don't really have anyone to prompt, and - more importantly - no time/energy to offer anything in return. But I figured it'd be as good a chance as any to put one of my favourite fanfic/AU scenarios out there. (By the bye: I've never visited the Plot Bunny Farm, so any overlap is purely coincidental)

Read more... )
winter_blossom: (Meganekko)
29. Rec a meta post

There's plenty of excellent meta here on DW, but [personal profile] rheasilvia 's timeline for the show and [personal profile] likealeafonthewind 's followup post strike me as particularly useful - not to mention impartial, so safe to rec to anyone regardless of their headcanons, ships, interests, etc.
winter_blossom: (Fluorescence)
28. Rec a fanart

Oh, come on, only one!? But it's true that if I start, I may never stop, so I'll go with this one. Chibi renditions of iconic scenes from the drama, very SFW and incredibly cute.

I can't find the original art no matter how much I try - Chinese websites are difficult to navigate, anyway - so the link above leads to a post on Tumblr, with the artist credited.
winter_blossom: (SnK - Armin)
27. Rec a vid

Another instance where Guardian proves itself the exception to my rules: I've watched dozens of fan videos and even a few behind-the-scenes clips for it, whereas I usually stay away from that kind of content.

This video by NodeZero really stood out to me because it's one of the rare ones which focus on Zhao Yunlan's feelings instead of Shen Wei's. There's really no need to prove the depths of Shen Wei's devotion, since we see innumerable instances of it in canon. But when I think critically about the canon evidence we have re: Zhao Yunlan's reciprocation, I feel it's a bit lacking in comparison, and often more "take it as you will" than anything concrete. This is not unique to Guardian: pretty much any story with a human-non-human relationship** - platonic or romantic - tends to portray the non-human's devotion much more intensely and obviously; it's particularly glaring when they're more powerful and/or longer-lived than their human partner. Part of this is likely the impracticability of trying to make a mortal's capacity for commitment measure up to an immortal's, while the other part is, well, definitely human arrogance.

Anyway, that's why I picked out the above vid: it brought up some nice points about Zhao Yunlan's love that tend to get buried under the absolute deluge of Shen Wei's.

** The novel doesn't have this problem, since that version of Zhao Yunlan isn't fully human himself, and is eventually revealed to be older and more powerful than Shen Wei, which allows him to fully understand - and reciprocate - Shen Wei's dedication and devotion. Drama!Yunlan is a much cooler, more heroic character than his novel counterpart in the present time, and I approve of that wholeheartedly, but I can't help but wish he'd been allowed to be sincerely affectionate now and then, instead of only teasing and flirtatious. The change was mostly for the benefit of the censors, I know, so what truly puzzles me is that they didn't make a corresponding change in Shen Wei when they adapted him; heck, the lack of overt possessiveness actually makes drama!Shen Wei's love sweeter. But since it's his devotion - not Yunlan's - that drives the plot of the show, it wouldn't make much sense to tone it down, I guess.
winter_blossom: (T&B - Barnaby)
26. Rec a fanfic

There's no way I can pick just one, so here are my AO3 bookmarks for Guardian. I'm diligent about adding tags and bookmark notes, so this can easily stand as a rec list.
winter_blossom: (Mystical Messenger - redhead megane)
25. Thoughts and feelings on the ending

The answer to this is two-fold. Would I have loved it if they'd defeated Ye Zun with minimum collateral damage and not a single sacrifice, and the story ended with, "Then the SID and the Black-Cloaked Envoy overhauled the whole political structure of Dixing, renegotiated the Treaty, worked towards dispelling anti-Dixingren/Yashouren attitudes among Haixingren (and vice versa) and worked towards creating a world where all three species could live and let live in relative harmony"? Hell, yes! Do I think it was feasible for the show writers to have pulled that off if they'd really wanted to? Also yes. However...

I thought I could get away without a cut, but who am I kidding? )
winter_blossom: (Flower shounen)
24. Favourite team moment

I've been missing way too many days lately, so today it's two for the price of one!

The Reunion Festival Dinner is a shoe-in for favourite team moment. The whole gang's together (even Lao Li!), they're all triumphant re: their recent heroics and enjoying themselves with good food, Zhao Yunlan and Shen Wei are doing one of their best "Dad and Dad's husband" impressions, and their silly banter - followed soon after by one of those awesome couple moments where they're basically alone in a crowd - is sheer joy to witness.

I think Guo Changcheng said it best: "So nice... This must be what family feels like!"

It was a very short-lived peace and happiness, sure, but all the more poignant for that same reason.
winter_blossom: (Boku wa ne - Akihito)
23. Favourite soft moment

There are lots of excellent candidates for this, but I decided on the one that leapt to my mind when I first saw the question, almost a month ago: The Bench Scene. Zhao Yunlan being so very himself, Shen Wei's indulgent-but-amused-against-his-best-judgement smile, and the way they both just...sat there, content with each other's company in a rare moment of calm at the eye of the storm, is something that will stay in my heart for a long, long time. And seeing Shen Wei lean against the seatback, close his eyes and relax, if only briefly, despite the memories of his ordeal in Dixing and the knowledge of what's surely about to happen soon, made me incredibly wistful for all the things I wanted him to have, though I suspected from the start he wouldn't get them.
winter_blossom: (Gem earring)
22. Favourite badass moment

Not really a "moment," per se, but the last stand against Ye Zun was one of the truly spectacular scenes in the drama, for me. Shen Wei, Zhao Yunlan, the rest of the SID... It was both stunning and poignant to see everyone coming together to perform what, in essence, would be their final act as a team in perfect sync in order to conquer that final, greatest threat.

Consider: Zhao Yunlan going absolutely all out with everything he had on hand to take Ye Zun down, the SID members fearlessly standing up to the Big Bad himself despite knowing they could never hold a candle to him, Guo Changcheng and Da Qing passing Yunlan the Mount-River Awl at exactly the right moment, Lin Jing making the - doubtless nerve-wracking - choice to stab Shen Wei, Shen Wei using the minuscule amount of power he had left to save Lin Jing, An Bai and the Regent before unleashing his final gambit... All culminating in that priceless look of furious shock on Ye Zun's face when he realised he'd lost after all.

If that isn't badass (in ALL CAPS), I can't imagine what is!
winter_blossom: (Meganekko)
21. Favourite character moment

I'll admit, I have no idea what the OP was actually expecting here. But my own take on it is that I'm supposed to pick a situation where the main characters acted in ways that speak firmly to the strength of their personalities and the nature of their convictions.

Considering this interpretation, what better choice than the latter half of episode 20, featuring Zhao Yunlan's first confrontation (in the present time, at least) with Ye Zun? It was one of the most impactful and memorable parts of the drama for me, because it spoke volumes about our heroes, the Big Bad, the Hallows and Zhao Yunlan and Shen Wei's relationship. To wit:
  • Zhao Yunlan shows us how far he's willing to go in order to fulfil his role as Haixing's Guardian.
  • Ye Zun proves that he's a melodramatic genocidal megalomaniac who wouldn't think twice before sacrificing even his closest allies.
  • Shen Wei proves that he will protect Zhao Yunlan come hell, high water or evil little brothers, and that he will always stand against Ye Zun, family bonds and childhood nostalgia be damned.
  • Zhao Yunlan proves that he trusts Shen Wei to be there whenever he truly needs him, and also to be the ultimate victor in a showdown against Ye Zun.
  • The Hallows prove that they're perfectly willing to help the Guardian perform his duties, for the appropriate price. Plus, that they're becoming progressively more overbearing in their attempts to manoeuvre Zhao Yunlan into helping them achieve their ultimate purpose.
  • A beautiful girl is clutching at Zhao Yunlan and desperately calling his name. Shen Wei is hovering nearby, silent. Even semi-conscious, Yunlan immediately turns in Shen Wei's direction, calls out his name and reaches out to him. Shen Wei, who rarely smiles genuinely and who is surely sick with worry right now over any number of things, nevertheless finds it impossible to stop the brightest, most beautiful grin from breaking out over his face when he thinks Yunlan is going to be okay. If that doesn't illustrate their relationship perfectly, I don't know what does!
Thinking back on it now, I almost wish I'd picked this episode for Day 1... But not really, because it got to feature plenty here.
winter_blossom: (SnK - Armin)
20. Favourite headcanons

Can't believe I missed three days in a row! But then again, I'm pretty sure my sister's the only one still reading these, so: Sorry, sweetie! Here you go. Better late than never, right?

This should probably have been worded in the singular, but I have several pet theories (which are vaguely interconnected). I know most of this isn't what the show writers intended, since "they tried to turn a supernatural fantasy universe into a sci-fi one and only partially succeeded" is the actual explanation for almost every illogical aspect of the drama, but, well, I do love coming up with elaborate explanations, so...

Obscenely long post, ahoy! )
winter_blossom: (Fluorescence)
19. If /when do you think Zhao Yunlan and Shen Wei get together?

I don't think they ever did, at least not physically. Don't get me wrong, I've read and loved many variants of "getting together" and "established relationship" fics for them, but my personal view is a bit different.

Read more... )
winter_blossom: (Sinister white)
18. Least favourite character

Skipping the original Day 18 question - Least favourite villain - and shifting the next couple of questions up because I want to add one of my own later.

Da Ji. What even was the point of her existence? She was supremely irritating and her weird rushed romance with Da Qing was awkward beyond belief. Surely there was a better way to work his amnesia plot into the story and let him regain his memories? Her arc was a strong contender for Least Favourite Case, but the Nightmare Master won out because I didn't actually skim anything in her episodes - though that was only thanks to Da Qing!

Da Ji was the only non-villain in the show whose death (the eventual, real one, not the one Shen Wei was responsible for, because, ouch!) didn't make me the slightest bit sad; I was almost relieved, to be honest. I feel a bit apologetic towards Da Qing for saying these things, but, well...
winter_blossom: (Mystical Messenger - redhead megane)
17. Favourite Dixing power and/or power you want to have

An easy one at last, since it can only be Shen Wei's power(s)!

They really didn't do enough with his ability, imo. When I think about all the potential there, I really wish Guardian had been a few seasons long, with a larger variety of cases so we could have seen some of his more obscure/less combat-oriented powers. Or even just more variations on the combat abilities.
winter_blossom: (Flower tea)
16. Favourite conversation between Zhao Yunlan and Shen Wei

After a long internal struggle (because, come on, 90% of their conversations could easily qualify), I decided on The Conversation in The Void at The End, because it had the strongest emotional impact on me (to the point where I know all the lines by heart even now, months after I last watched that scene) and was also the conversation in which they were both, finally, 100% on the same page, zero secrets between them. Plus, that last promise was the bandage I needed to bind the pieces of my shattered heart together after the finale...

Other favourites:

1. Their discussion of the Mirror Girl case, which was the first time it truly struck them both how well they worked together.

2. The conversation after The Mugging, both in the alley and at Shen Wei's place. Always nice to see the rare moments where Zhao Yunlan fails at his "smooth suave playboy" act.

3. Their adorable banter/bickering in the Fight Club case, both in the office and outside the kidnappers' building.

4. Teen!Shen Wei's talk with Zhao Yunlan in the YOHE arc - But only under the assumption that the former and latter halves actually took place on different days, preferably with several weeks in-between. (To pimp out my favourite YOHE fic, see [personal profile] xparrot 's Now Lie In It for the exact the scenario I have in mind)

Call me weird, but I never liked The Kitchen Scene much. Zhu Yilong and Bai Yu's acting was spectacular, but the actual conversation was way too tense and uncomfortable for me. And for all that Zhao Yunlan saw there, he didn't seem to learn anything from it and still kept going off to Dixing, touching the Hallows, taking stupid risks...overall acting the same as usual after the initial argument was resolved. That conversation got my hopes up without leading to any improvements on the emotion/relationship front, which really bothered me. I did appreciate the excellent foreshadowing it provided on the plot front, though.
winter_blossom: (Meganekko)
15. Villain you'd like redeemed Scene/arc you wish had been expanded on

Why, yes, I did pick this question specifically to give myself a chance to rant about the YOHE arc! Because that's the one point where I honestly thought the plot went off the rails in a way that cannot be salvaged unless we studiously ignore all evidence to the contrary and just take it on the most meagre of throwaway comments/hints that Zhao Yunlan spent at least a month in the past. Whatever you want to read his relationship with past Shen Wei as, it still would not make sense for anyone - not even adorably naive teen!Shen Wei and considerably-less-jaded kitten!Da Qing - to imprint on him to that extent without at least a few weeks spent, say, fighting and strategising and camping and sharing meals together.

And then there was how quickly and ludicrously the battle with Ye Zun over the Hallows was resolved. I have no words, really.

Which is why the YOHE arc is the one part of the show where I'll take fanon over canon any day.
winter_blossom: (Sinister white)
14. Favourite villain

I rarely have special feelings - positive or negative - towards villains. If they're really annoying and seem to exist just to be pests rather than to pose a genuine threat, I might hate them, but as long as a villain fulfils their role by being resourceful enough to pose a good challenge for the heroes, I'm satisfied. By that logic, the Big Bad would always have to be my favourite. While that isn't the case with everything I've read or watched, Guardian has the classic type of Big Bad in Ye Zun, so I do still pick him.

However! I feel compelled to specify that I only like him as a villain. I have no intention of defending his actions and no particular wish for him to be given a second chance** I really don't buy into the "villain redemption" trend that's all the rage in fandom nowadays, because redeeming a villain strikes me as robbing them of the opportunity to do what they do best, what we admire them for excelling at: being the villain. I like Ye Zun because he's a powerful, determined and intelligent opponent who, despite being defeated in the end, actually managed to take both heroes down with him. That's a pretty amazing accomplishment in my book. If he were persuaded away from evil somehow, it would not only deny him the chance to shine his brightest, but also deprive the story of its best antagonist.

I did love his and Shen Wei's reunion beyond the grave, though, for the closure it gave to that particular plot thread and the implication that when they all meet again next time like was promised at the end (yes, that will always be THE post-finale headcanon for me), he'll not be axe-crazy for once and let my poor children live in peace!

** I have no objection to AU's where he's had the chance to grow up with Shen Wei or somehow resolve their differences and curb his murderous tendencies, but after reading several such fics where he has more chemistry with Zhao Yunlan than Shen Wei does, I'm now weary of even those. Normally I'd attribute this to my not being a multishipper, but in all honesty: even if I were a multishipper the last person on Haixing or Dixing or any other universe I'd ship Zhao Yunlan with would be Ye Zun ^_^
winter_blossom: (Adorable cat 1)
13. Favourite Yashou tribe

Cat, obviously! I choose to believe that there are actually other Cat Yashou out there, and Da Qing and Da Ji just don't know/remember. Cats are strictly solitary creatures, after all; it's hard to believe that they'd want to be tied down by tribe politics, so they probably keep to themselves, maybe flitting from "owner" to "owner" in cat form, maybe living as normal humans, who knows? It's too sad to think that Da Qing might be the last. He'd definitely still be the King of Cats, though - if nothing else through sheer seniority!
winter_blossom: (Gem earring)
12. Favourite platonic relationship

Since I skipped the original #11 and replaced it with #12, I'll go with a question of my own here.

The answer is, obviously, Da Qing and Zhao Yunlan. Comfortable, funny and heartwarming despite being full of cheek and sass: in short, the best kind of friendship!

On Shen Wei's side, I found his relationships with Chu Shuzhi (special mention to the moment between them after Shen Wei's identity was revealed to the SID), Li Qian and Dr. Cheng to be really nice, in three completely different ways. Also, proof that he isn't the social misfit he's interpreted as so often!
Page generated Jun. 13th, 2025 05:48 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios